Chat EPDocs

Keyword vs semantic vs AI-first search: what is the difference?

Keyword search matches terms. Semantic search matches meaning. AI-first search reads intent before the results page is built.

Empathy Teamby Empathy Team

Keyword search matches terms. Semantic search matches meaning. AI-assisted search adds AI on top of a relevance engine. AI-first search puts the AI in front: it reads the shopper's intent first, then decides what kind of response to build.

The difference between keyword, semantic and AI-first search is where understanding happens. Keyword search understands nothing and matches text. Semantic search understands meaning and returns closer results. AI-first search understands intent before the results page exists, so it can change the response itself as well as the ranking.

Take one query: ‘anti-wrinkle serum with vitamin C and hyaluronic acid’. A keyword engine sees eight words. An AI-first search box sees what the shopper wants: a product type, a concern and two ingredients.

Keyword search, also called lexical search, matches the words in a query against the words in product data. It is fast, predictable and exact. It works for ‘nike air max 42’ and for stock keeping units (SKUs). It fails when the shopper's words differ from the catalogue's, which is why it depends on synonym lists someone has to maintain.

Semantic search matches the meaning of a query, even when the words differ. It turns queries and products into vectors, numerical representations of meaning, and returns the products closest to the query. ‘Something warm for a ski trip’ can find thermal jackets with none of those words in the title.

Two terms get confused with it:

Semantic search vs vector search

Vector search is the technique: finding the nearest vectors. Semantic search is the outcome: results matched on meaning. Most semantic search runs on vector search.

Hybrid search

Hybrid search runs keyword and vector matching together and blends the results. It keeps exact matches for SKUs and brand names and adds meaning for everything else.

Semantic search improves the list of results. It still returns a list every time, whatever the shopper asked.

AI-assisted search layers AI features on top of keyword search and keeps the relevance engine underneath. It keeps the speed and control of the search you already run and adds AI understanding where keyword search falls short: refining a query, recovering from zero results and predicting what to search next.

In Empathy.co, AI-assisted search includes AI Semantics, AI Spell Check, AI Carousels, Related Prompts and Next Queries. The features generate suggestions from a large language model and your catalogue, so they work from day one without tagging or months of behavioural data. They run on self-hosted, open models on Empathy.co's own infrastructure.

AI-assisted search makes the results page better. The kind of response stays the same: the results page is still the default answer to every query.

AI-first search reverses the order. The AI reads the intent before the results page is built, then chooses the response and the interface for that moment. A product query gets precise results. A broad query gets refinements. A question gets an answer grounded in the retailer's content.

AI-First means the AI comes before the results page.

AI-first search builds on the steps before it. It still uses exact matching for a SKU and semantic matching for a description. What changes is that something decides which one the moment needs.

How do the four approaches compare?

Keyword searchSemantic searchAI-assisted searchAI-first search
UnderstandsTextMeaningMeaning, with AI features addedIntent, before the response is built
Long queries (4+ terms)Often zero or loose resultsCloser resultsCloser resultsReads each part: type, concern, attributes
QuestionsTreated as keywordsTreated as a product querySometimes a summaryA grounded answer with products
InterfaceOne results pageOne results pageOne results page with extrasAdapts to the moment
Merchandising controlRules on the listRules on the listVaries by vendorThe AI understands, the retailer's rules decide
Where the model runsNo modelVaries by vendorVaries by vendor. For Empathy.co: self-hostedFor Empathy.co: self-hosted, on private infrastructure
Model behaviour over timeNo modelVaries by vendorVaries by vendor. For Empathy.co: pinned versionsFor Empathy.co: pinned versions, changed on a published calendar
AI at peak trafficNo modelVaries by vendorOften metered per requestFor Empathy.co: on for every query within installed capacity
Shopper data pathYour search providerVaries by vendorMay pass to a third-party model APIFor Empathy.co: private EU infrastructure, one data processing agreement

Why does it matter where the model runs?

In AI-first search, a model reads every query before the results page is built. The model sits in the path of every search, so where it runs shapes four things shoppers and retailers notice.

Peak trading

Per-token API pricing, and now peak-hour pricing, pushes retailers to ration AI features when traffic is highest. Self-hosted models have a largely fixed cost within installed capacity, so AI stays on for every query, including on Black Friday.

Consistent results

API providers update and retire models on their own schedule. Empathy.co pins the model version and changes it on a published release calendar after benchmarking. The same query behaves the same way next quarter, and merchandising rules keep working.

Shopper data

Search queries and behaviour are personal data. With Empathy.co they are processed on private EU infrastructure, with no third-party model provider in the request path and one data processing agreement for the whole service.

Relevance built as one system

Retrieval, reranking and the model that reads intent are engineered and tuned together on the retailer's catalogue. Improving relevance depends on Empathy.co and the retailer alone, with no outside model vendor setting the roadmap.

Which approach does your store need?

It depends on what your shoppers type. If most queries are one or two words, semantic or hybrid search covers the gap. If long queries and questions are growing, a results list is the wrong answer to many of them. Queries of four or more terms grew 71% in a year.

Check your own logs for three things:

  1. The share of queries with four or more terms.
  2. The share phrased as questions.
  3. The zero-results rate on both.

Then ask your vendor three questions: where does the model run, who can change it, and what happens to AI features at peak traffic?

AI-First Commerce Search was pioneered by Empathy.co, the commerce search company behind search for over 3,000 brands. Empathy.co introduced the approach in 2026 as one adaptive search box, designed for people and for the agents shopping on their behalf. It runs on self-hosted AI with pinned model versions, processes shopper data in the EU and keeps merchandising rules in the retailer's hands.

Frequently asked questions

Semantic search is one kind of AI search. It uses a model to match meaning. AI-first search goes further: it uses AI to decide what kind of response the query needs.

Neither is better alone. Vector search handles descriptions and vague queries. Keyword search handles SKUs, model numbers and brand names. Hybrid search combines them.

Natural language search lets shoppers type the way they speak, in full phrases or questions. Semantic, AI-assisted and AI-first search all support it to different degrees.

No. AI-first search still uses exact matching where the query calls for it. It adds a layer that reads intent and picks the right response.

What does ‘AI-first’ mean?

In search, AI-first means the AI reads the shopper's intent before the results page is built, then chooses the response. The AI shapes the whole response from the first moment.

Does AI-first search send my shoppers' queries to a third-party AI provider?

With Empathy.co, no. Models run on self-hosted infrastructure in the EU, covered by one data processing agreement.

Will AI-first search behave differently after a model update?

Empathy.co pins model versions and releases changes on a published calendar after benchmarking, so retailers know when behaviour will change.

Is AI-first search more expensive to run at peak times?

On per-token APIs it can be. Self-hosted models keep the cost largely fixed within installed capacity, so AI features stay on when traffic is highest.

Free Search Audit

See which of your queries a results list cannot answer

We run your store's real queries and show you where keyword, semantic and AI-first search would give a different answer.